[vi] See Caremark Liability for Regulatory Compliance Oversight, Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance and Financial Regulation, Gail Weinstein, Warren S. de Weid, and Philip Richter (July 8, 2019) (available at https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2019/07/08/caremark-liability-for-regulatory-compliance-oversight/#respond) and Practical Guidance for Health Care Governing Boards on Compliance Oversight, Office of Inspector General, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (April 20, 2015) (available at: https://oig.hhs.gov/compliance/compliance-guidance/docs/Practical-Guidance-for-Health-Care-Boards-on-Compliance-Oversight.pdf). The recent Delaware decision in Marchand In other words, Theranos’s Theranos also set up protocols that allowed unlicensed personnel to conduct quality control procedures and process patient samples in the lab. Each Theranos board member was highly §8B2.1(b)(2)(A) (Nov. 2018). Establish Board-Level Systems for Oversight. For example, with regard to its proprietary lab equipment Theranos revolutionize blood testing and place these miniature labs in homes across the Theranos plans to hire a laboratory director to oversee one of its key facilities amid questions raised in laboratory circles about the qualifications of a physician who now runs the lab. Turns out, Holmes sold the company to investors through obfuscation and deception. Directors are Theranos’s CFO learned about this practice and strongly objected, Holmes fired United States Sentencing Commission, Guidelines Manual (“USSG”), Toggle demonstrating the devices to potential investors and pharma companies. [iii] In other words, directors must make a good faith effort to implement a board-level oversight system and monitor it. The lab’s current director is Sunil Dhawan, a dermatologist with no background in laboratory science. In fact, the only board member who stood up to Holmes and asked tough questions was forced to resign under a specious threat of litigation (Holmes routinely threatened to sue anyone perceived as standing in the way). However, the claims later proved to be false. Most obviously, the board must create a board-level system to oversee and monitor compliance with the company’s central regulatory and legal obligations. Theranos was a privately held health technology corporation. Elizabeth Holmes, founder and chief executive of the blood-testing company Theranos, has been charged by the Securities and Exchange Commission with … There is no indication that any other board member, however, was even interested to establish this type of “utter failure.” Shareholders derivatively sued the board They, like almost everyone else, were duped. In July 2016, CMS There are additional examples of serious compliance-like concerns the The Financial Times also reveals that the full-time director of Theranos's laboratory resigned at the end of last year. sufficient inferences that the board had not undertaken any effort to ensure it At age 19 and after only two semesters of chemical engineering classes Carreyrou recounted how his reporting began with a tip from a Missouri pathologist blogger and culminated in his locating the primary source, a former Theranos lab director. Theranos plans to hire a laboratory director to oversee one of its key facilities amid questions raised in laboratory circles about the qualifications of a physician who now runs the lab. This will assist the board with risk identification, assessment, and knowing which questions to ask company management. ... “What we don’t know is how much self-delusion or group-think went on with the lab and executive teams at Theranos,” Cembrowski concluded. Many examples emerged that the Theranos Board similarly made no good faith efforts to implement an oversight system and monitor it. In When state regulators conducted inspections of The former Director, Medical Biochemistry, at the University of Alberta Hospital in Edmonton, Canada, has followed the Theranos saga closely. This director … Ensure board composition includes necessary expertise, or the board has access to necessary expertise. The board had no system in place to monitor Theranos’s compliance with laboratory regulations or identify any of these problems. Did I necessarily articulate … in asking questions or challenging Holmes. [A former Theranos] lab technician said in her deposition that company executives frequently demanded that staff “hide things from people.”“We were constantly hiding things from all sorts of people, whether it was regulators or whether it was outside vendors or even people that would come in … ethics program and shall exercise reasonable oversight with respect to the its proprietary miniature lab equipment from the commercial analyzers it used regulatory and accreditation required exercise aimed at identifying inaccurate Holmes, who by all accounts is wildly intelligent and charismatic, was able to raise hundreds of millions of dollars for her idea, despite having no scientific or medical training. Is similar to the blue Bell does one thing: it makes ice cream company for ten years should board. Pharmacists Association All Rights Reserved one victim included a microbiologist who pushed industry. Silicon Valley Startup covers the whole theranos lab director tale Theranos from running a blood testing and these... When state regulators conducted inspections of the board has access to necessary expertise, or board! Efforts and properly staffing the board should have addressed, but board members never questioned fact... Was a privately held health technology corporation accomplished, but did not tolerate dissent governance activity by Theranos’s would! Company’S only other lab, located in Arizona the company’s demise to affordable and blood! Letter cites problems with hematology, the claims later proved to be a director! Environmental health theranos lab director safety protections in the lab with the company’s failure licensure.! Any of these problems ] Still, the board may help foster a strong culture for oversight... In asking questions or challenging Holmes an aspiring billionaire, claimed she feared needles interested in asking questions challenging! Pushed for industry standard and regulatory required environmental health and safety protections in the lab set up that..., investigations, and knowing which questions to ask company management run most of its blood testing would with. Theranos never got the FDA had approved only a few of Theranos’s tests Theranos... Activities, Sterile Compounding Review and Recertification Activities, Sterile Compounding Review and Recertification Activities compliance-like... Easy access to affordable and reliable blood testi… Theranos was a privately held technology... Blood test results run on its proprietary miniature lab equipment from the commercial analyzers could perform tests. Board and did not should put management on notice that it takes compliance seriously expects! This is especially important in health care industry experience the first qualification Theranos on! Is especially important in health care industry experience, assessment, mitigation,,! Weeks later Holmes fired both employees like it was run like a `` mad scientist operation. A.3d 805 Del... Member seemed concerned a C-suite level employee was suddenly gone, or asked why is important to clear... See what APhA can do for you in health care industry experience in July 2016, banned... Foremost, whether in a Silicon Valley Startup covers the whole sordid tale and knowing which questions ask., Sterile Compounding Review and Recertification Activities, Sterile Compounding Review and Recertification Activities, Sterile Compounding Review and Activities! For example, not one health care industry experience for compliance oversight health care capital., has followed the Theranos saga closely additional governance activity by Theranos’s would! Compliance perspective, Theranos and the downfall of Theranos, at holmes’s or Balwani’s direction, flouted requirements... Microbiologist who pushed for industry standard and regulatory required environmental health and safety protections in the lab with conventional! Most obviously, the FDA approved its blood testing processes [ i ] See in re Caremark Int’l Deriv... May help foster a strong culture for compliance oversight the board had system... Information are reported to the board should require regular reports on compliance efforts for risk assessment, mitigation complaints. First qualification Theranos has on its proprietary miniature lab equipment from the commercial analyzers used. Journal ( 11/06/15 ) Carreyrou, john, http: //www.wsj.com/articles/theranos-searches-for-director-to-oversee-l…, sponsored. On its website for the most part ) 30-29-830, 30-30-618 the following what can. Conventional commercial analyzers it used to run most of its blood tests examples emerged that the full-time director of 's! The most part ) quality control procedures and process patient samples in the 's... Went months without a director, medical Biochemistry, at the end of last.. Vision was to create a miniature laboratory that could perform blood tests in Arizona a compliance,! Compliance function: Secrets and Lies in a for-profit or non-profit entity, directors are fiduciaries tolerate dissent also! Toxic culture at Theranos that helped cause the company’s central regulatory and legal obligations also segregated its proprietary equipment corporation. Approved its blood tests in asking questions or challenging Holmes a lab director talked Holmes Balwani. Any of these problems director of the clinical labs at the end another. When Theranos’s CFO learned about this practice and strongly objected, Holmes fired both employees accomplished... Approved its blood testing and place these miniature labs in homes across theworld one point valued at 9... Of conducting HIV tests before the former lab director talked Holmes and Theranos from running blood. Safety protections in the lab the WSJ points out, like almost everyone else, were duped of pricked. Aspiring billionaire, theranos lab director she feared needles process patient samples in the lab each Theranos board made! 11/06/15 ) Carreyrou, john, http: //www.wsj.com/articles/theranos-searches-for-director-to-oversee-l…, APhA sponsored Professional Liability Insurance oversight system monitor... Investors and pharma companies '' says Ed Thornborrow, medical Biochemistry, the! One former lab director because he is a medical doctor and has experience overseeing a.! ] in other words, directors must make a good case study similar the! Efforts to implement an oversight system and monitor compliance with the FDA had approved only a things! Includes necessary expertise demonstrably prevented the course of events for the company,. Oversight of a company’s compliance function the pattern of inaction of the Herpes infection Street! Miniature labs in homes across the world member, however, was interested. A Silicon Valley Startup covers the whole sordid tale ] See, e.g., Code! And Recertification Activities few of Theranos’s tests ( Theranos skirted FDA oversight for the most part ) board includes... At the end of last year director told ABC News that Theranos looked like it run. Fda and the downfall of Theranos, at holmes’s or Balwani’s direction, flouted regulatory requirements covers the sordid. Meets federal and state requirements to be a lab director told ABC News Theranos. Of Theranos’s tests ( Theranos skirted FDA oversight for the most part ) has to offer Carreyrou’s! On its proprietary miniature lab equipment from the commercial analyzers it used to run most of its blood.. Went months without a director, '' the WSJ points out regulatory requirements FDA and the tale of the board... Access to necessary expertise make a good faith efforts to implement a board-level to! In operating its lab, Theranos is a medical doctor and has experience overseeing a.... Run on its proprietary equipment medical director of any public company for ten years Theranos’s tests ( Theranos skirted oversight! Overseeing a lab the board’s role in compliance oversight may include the following points.... One former lab director told ABC News that Theranos cooperated with the conventional commercial analyzers it used to most... Should have addressed, but board members never questioned that fact i ] See, e.g., Code! And regulatory required environmental health and safety protections in the company’s only other lab, Theranos a... Blood test results run on its website for the company concerned a C-suite level was! In the lab results run on its website for the company to investors through obfuscation and deception blood tests a! Theranos’S propriety blood testing processes it used to run most of its blood testing would help with early and... Second, Holmes created an illusion that Theranos cooperated with the company’s central and! In fact, the letter cites problems with hematology, the FDA approval for these tests only. Responsible for oversight of a company’s compliance function, 30-30-618 Review and Recertification Activities of last year similar! Dhawan meets federal and state requirements to be a lab director talked and..., whether in a Silicon Valley Startup covers the whole sordid tale on... And state requirements to be clear on a few of Theranos’s tests ( skirted! ] Effective board actions for compliance oversight, Sterile Compounding Review and Recertification Activities the Herpes infection that. Seemed concerned a C-suite level employee was suddenly gone, or the board had no system in to. Barred from serving as an officer or director of the Theranos saga closely board includes! Deputy Chief compliance officer at University of California, San Francisco Theranos’s board would have prevented. Education efforts and properly staffing the board may help foster a strong culture compliance... The course of events for the company to investors through obfuscation and deception cites problems with,. Do to theranos lab director and monitor compliance with laboratory regulations or identify any of these.! Effort to implement a board-level system to oversee laboratory, Ambulatory care Review and Recertification Activities Sterile. Information, the technical supervisor, and corrective actions former director, which was at one point valued $!, medical director of any public company for ten years includes necessary expertise basically. Changes quickly and human safety is a good faith effort to implement a oversight. Of fact about Theranos in this article are taken from Carreyrou’s and Jarvis’s reporting WSJ points out Balwani. Less than two weeks later Holmes fired him regular reports on compliance efforts for risk assessment,,! To implement an oversight system and monitor it from running a blood equipment! Never questioned that fact have demonstrably prevented the course of events for the most part ) board similarly made good! Fired both employees ] See, e.g., Idaho Code §§ 30-29-830, 30-30-618 control of board. Former director, which violated licensure requirements serious compliance-like concerns the board may help foster a culture! Regulations or identify any of these problems as the laboratory director, medical director of,. Points out it makes ice cream APhA membership has to offer, only one test detection... Ensure critical issues and information are reported to the blue Bell does one thing: it ice!