2. Honest opinions shared by friends and neighbors. Doctors Doctors are persons who are entitled to be provisionally registered as a medical practitioner (Medical Act 1971, Sec 29). Is there really an oversupply? A person working in Doctor / Physician in Malaysia typically earns around 15,500 MYR per month. This is fresh MO i'm talking about. Fewer places for medicine due to glut of doctors, says ministry The Malaysian Insider. However, the situation in Australia is such that you will be in the 3rd category to get an internship post. Doctors in … The system that we had in the past, when there is a permanent post, a doctor had adequate training, got Master’s in speciality, and all fully trained under government facilities. By the end of 2010, there were approximately 33,000 doctors in Malaysia, and for a population of 28.35 million, that gives a doctor to population ratio of about 1:850. Step 2: Enrol in a MBBS Degree that’s typically 5 years long. Well gov doctors who work at district hospital in Sabah easily get 9-10k permonth. Previously, Government medical officers were enjoying a remarkable RM80/hour (considerably above the market locum doctor rates to the envy of private GPs) for extended OPD hours but now it seems, there may be a “shift system” for the MOs manning Government OPDs. He said this is because Malaysia currently has 71,041 medical doctors working in both public and private sectors, making a ratio of one doctor for every 454 people. This leads to cost-containment measures, including resorting to short-term contract jobs for fresh doctors. Unwanted Citizen, a doctor in Malaysia, wrote on his blog in 2008 that up to 40 per cent of doctors in the Lion City of Singapore are Malaysians. A multi-pronged solution looking at both demand-side factors and supply-side factors and requiring the sustained commitment of all stakeholders concerned needs to be put in place. From the graph, the number of doctors is increasing exponentially and the trend suggests we shall have about 65,000 doctors by 2020. A-Level, STPM, Foundation in Science) after SPM. Malaysian healthcare … And the glut does not affect just doctors, but also pharmacists and dentists. While this also looks to be a strategy in line with the rule of microeconomics as outlined above (since supply is abundant, prices or salaries come down), there are huge questions of equity and efficiency involved here as well, as has been raised by many stakeholders. “There are no places when they finish their housemanship. "Some quarters estimate that between one to two million Malaysians are currently serving a foreign country," the Unwanted Citizen blogged. Only with this can one work as a doctor anywhere in Malaysia for whichever establishment. Today, it looks simple: A glut in doctors, to the extent that the public sector is unable to provide critical training and internship so that they are legally registered to work in Malaysia. For example, if a student studies marketing at any university in the world, comes back to Malaysia and applies for a job, any employer can employ him or her as long as they feel that the candidate is suitable for their establishment. I estimate that Malaysia now has more than 57,000 existing doctors. Recognising more overseas medical schools to enable more Malaysians to pursue medicine. The oversupply of medical doctors in Malaysia has long been an issue in our country, and it’s up to the government to come up with a new plan because the current one is just a temporary solution. The answer, unfortunately, is no. There is no place in the civil service to absorb them, even as a medical officer. According to the Malaysian Medical Council, Malaysia has 27,709 doctors (including 3,651 house officers). Guide for doctors looking for a job in Malaysia. Doctors still remain in short supply throughout the public sector. Quek said the health ministry and the government had no clue how to place these newly-qualified house officers and medical officers. In the UK that is, as reported in the Telegraph (hat tip to Dr Punna Wong for the link) Up to 1,000 new doctors will face unemployment next year as there are too few training places available, it has been … Up to 1,000 new doctors could face unemployment Read more » No more waiting rooms. He said the country had overproduced doctors over the last 10 years. Malaysia is one of the developing countries that falls under this category (Gubb and Herbert, 2009). Copyright © 2020 FMT Media Sdn Bhd. Trusted by Doctors and Consumers. Looking at Malaysia with a population of 32 million, we have 34 medical schools at last count, producing about 4,000 doctors annually, combined with more than 1,000 returning from overseas. Best Prices in Malaysia. Unfortunately, no one consulted the right economists when decisions were made about attempting to bring market forces into play by creating a larger supply of doctors in Malaysia to satisfy the demand for doctors. The actual numbers are not publicly available, because the latest Malaysian Medical Council Annual Report dates back to 2016 . This is 74.64% lower of what Masters Degree degree holders earn. It doesn’t work that way for doctors. DASH and SUKE will offer alternative routes that will ease road congestion. In the language of economics, this concept is explained as such: the price of certain goods will vary until it settles at a point where the quantity demanded is equal to the quantity supplied, resulting in an economic equilibrium for price and quantity. The answer to the glut is obvious as we are producing too many doctors too fast. Phone: 03-8996 8700 , 03-8996 5700 The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT. Technology Park Malaysia 57000 Bukit Jalil Kuala Lumpur Malaysia. This is the general pathway to become a doctor in Malaysia. On the other hand, if there are 10 nasi lemak sellers, each with 10 packets of nasi lemak but only five buyers, the sellers are going to be desperately selling their nasi lemak at the lowest price. “In 2009, we decided to have a doctor to population ratio of 1:400 but the system cannot absorb this that quickly. Definition of Doctor Glut in the Medical Dictionary by The Free Dictionary All Rights Reserved. Ahli keluarga Zeti mengaku terima wang 1MDB, Confirmed – Zeti’s kin admitted knowing of 1MDB funds in SD, Malay politics at its ‘dirtiest and most divided’, M is for Malay support, declares Mahathir, Sham agreement drawn up to conceal bribes for Rosmah, says prosecution, Clear air on 1MDB funds, Patriot tells Zeti, Nine feared drowned after vehicle falls off ferry, DAP made it on its own, Kit Siang tells Dr M, APEC 2020: Putrajaya envisions a dynamic community, APEC 2020 mural brightens mood in downtown KL, SUKE, DASH highways will spur economic growth, say experts, Residents eager for shorter commutes via new highways, Bee Nazwin, Seberang Perai’s saviour of the strays, Econsave denies selling imported meat with fake halal logo, 4-month-old toddler among 9 victims inside vehicle which fell off ferry, Amanah Youth pleads with Dr M to stop attacks on Anwar, Old bill shock in new home for shoebox family, Tragedi 9 lemas: Kenderaan hilang kawalan sebelum jatuh sungai, kata polis, Ahli farmasi AS ditahan sabotaj vaksin COVID-19. This site is a directory of Malaysian Doctors and is a unique self maintained listing – essentially a directory of doctors, by doctors, for doctors. DASH and SUKE will offer alternative routes that will ease road congestion. Then the numbers may drop.”. As with most problems, there is no direct solution. It’s very easy to Search for a doctor in this site using the Find a doctor options in the Directory. The usual “supply and demand” rule of the market will apply. “Malaysia has been one of the best countries in Asia with the best training programmes and the doctors that we produce are competent. Quek said the skill sets of doctors are poor partly because there is not enough supervision nowadays. Speedoc brings Doctors, Nurses, Ambulance & Medicine to wherever you are in Malaysia, whenever you need. By the end of 2010, there were approximately 33,000 doctors in Malaysia, and for a population of 28.35 million, that gives a doctor to population ratio of about 1:850. COVID Test, Health Supplements, Home Nursing & Physiotherapy & Health Info The eye-grabbing work attracts the attention of passersby while also giving them a simple explanation of the APEC 2020 summit, organised by Malaysia. Salaries range from 5,680 MYR (lowest average) to 26,100 MYR (highest average, actual maximum salary is higher).. “We need to rethink how we look at that,” he said at a roundtable of Human Capital for Healthcare in Malaysia today at the Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall. In fact, one of the core things you study as a health economist is the idea of market failure in healthcare. Opening private medical schools; or Even when they have graduated, they cannot get into the job market before attaining full registration and undergoing the competency assessment process. The government has offered places to only 418 brilliant students to take up medical studies (first degree) at public institutions of higher learning for this year's intake. Step 1: Complete a pre-medical course (e.g. “One of the ways is to tell the parents out there that there is no place, no job in future for their children. The main premises of the author/editors is totally wrong that there is a glut of doctors in a country with a huge population. For 2012 graduates of Monash Malaysia, only 7 out of 60 who applied got internship in Australia. This is the average monthly salary including housing, transport, and other benefits. Earlier this year, the Health Ministry has started offering jobs to medical graduates on a 4-year contract basis […] Many people have the idea that once there is an abundant supply to satisfy demand, prices i.e. Some of these doctors are from overseas and some from local private universities, he added. KUALA LUMPUR: The health ministry has pledged to solve the glut of medical graduates and new nurses who have yet to get placement in government hospitals. None of the medical degree from Malaysia is recognised overseas except Monash Malaysia, which is recognised in Australia/NZ. “Doctors in Malaysia, on the other hand, often have to be on call and the hours could stretch from 8am to 5pm the following day,” said Dr Munawwar Salim, an executive member of IMAM. About 6,000 doctors come out every year but there are not enough jobs for them, according to an NGO. Housemanship in Malaysia – problems with the glut August 9th, 2011 | Author: palmdoc The shortage of doctors in Malaysia was a problem of the past, unfortunately addressed not by stemming resignations but by instead churning out medical graduates from the over 20 medical schools in this relatively small country, not counting those returning from overseas medical schools. Number of Doctors in Malaysia vs Population and projected trend. Today, it looks simple: A glut in doctors, to the extent that the public sector is unable to provide critical training and internship so that they are legally registered to work in Malaysia. A basic concept in microeconomics is the law of supply and demand. A solution that the government has proposed is to move new, fully registered medical officers to contract jobs, with a lower pay compared to those who have permanent jobs. Although WHO prescribes a doctor-population ratio of … Functionally, medical doctors examine, diagnose and treat patients. The initiative will allow member countries in the Asia-Pacific region to plan for a crisis, and prioritise innovation and digitalisation. KUALA LUMPUR: Former Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) president Dr David KL Quek has warned the government of a serious glut of doctors, saying there were not enough positions for these medical graduates at various hospitals. The idea of an ideal doctor population ratio is outdated and impractical. This is what has led us into this nightmare situation where everyone is unhappy and there is seemingly no end in sight. doctorDB is the most trusted healthcare platform in Malaysia. All these moves were put in place to resolve the issue of the demand for doctors. Doctors, like other professional vocations, need to be certified as competent. All Rights Reserved. In Dresden the price is 262% more expensive than in Kuala Lumpur In Leipzig the price is 147% more expensive than in Kuala Lumpur Ahli keluarga Zeti mengaku terima wang 1MDB, Confirmed – Zeti’s kin admitted knowing of 1MDB funds in SD, Malay politics at its ‘dirtiest and most divided’, M is for Malay support, declares Mahathir, Sham agreement drawn up to conceal bribes for Rosmah, says prosecution, Clear air on 1MDB funds, Patriot tells Zeti, Nine feared drowned after vehicle falls off ferry, DAP made it on its own, Kit Siang tells Dr M, APEC 2020: Putrajaya envisions a dynamic community, APEC 2020 mural brightens mood in downtown KL, SUKE, DASH highways will spur economic growth, say experts, Residents eager for shorter commutes via new highways, Bee Nazwin, Seberang Perai’s saviour of the strays, Econsave denies selling imported meat with fake halal logo, 4-month-old toddler among 9 victims inside vehicle which fell off ferry, Amanah Youth pleads with Dr M to stop attacks on Anwar, Old bill shock in new home for shoebox family, Tragedi 9 lemas: Kenderaan hilang kawalan sebelum jatuh sungai, kata polis, Ahli farmasi AS ditahan sabotaj vaksin COVID-19. “It was a misconceived plan, without adequate thought and serious projection of logistics, manpower or amenity capacities.”. This is due to one large stumbling block called government regulation. 1.2.2 Healthcare System in Malaysia The healthcare system in Malaysia has experienced considerable transformation since independence in 1957. So many medical graduates are still waiting for jobs. KUALA LUMPUR: Former Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) president Dr David KL Quek has warned the government of a serious glut of doctors, saying … They can specialise in a number of areas such as paediatrics, anaesthesiology or cardiology, or they can work as In Malaysia, the path to this is the two-year internship period, followed by a compulsory service period, and subsequently full registration from the Malaysian Medical Council. The two highways are expected to ease congestion, increase transport access and help micro-businesses in the long run. This leads to a bottleneck due to limited training posts for training interns or “house officers”. As one friend puts it, “many shophouses became medical universities overnight”. If there is one person selling 10 packets of nasi lemak with 100 people wanting to buy, the seller is free to set any price he thinks those wanting the nasi lemak are willing to pay. salaries and other costs related to doctors will come down. While Doctor workers with Bachelors Degree education earn the least, with an average gross income of MYR 99,039. Salaries vary drastically between different Doctor / Physician careers. Copyright © 2020 FMT Media Sdn Bhd. Russians plot Japan shock in World Cup opener, Federal Court strikes out prosecution’s appeal in Jong Nam trial, A better 2021 beckons for cleaner and diabetic husband, Probe bullying of medical staff, Cuepacs tells health ministry, MMA calls for greater regulation of growing online healthcare services, Sah! The initiative will allow member countries in the Asia-Pacific region to plan for a crisis, and prioritise innovation and digitalisation. The two highways are expected to ease congestion, increase transport access and help micro-businesses in the long run. Genuine Healthcare Products. The eye-grabbing work attracts the attention of passersby while also giving them a simple explanation of the APEC 2020 summit, organised by Malaysia. In some localities as well as in multiple specialist services throughout the country, there are acute shortages. “Don’t give loans to those who want to go into private medical universities. In 2012, for example, then-health minister Liow Tiong Lai said the doctor to patient ratio was 1 to 600, and that it would be 1:400 by 2020, exceeding what WHO wanted. Doctor workers holding Masters Degree degrees enjoy the highest average gross salaries in Malaysia. In simple terms, the price will be fixed when supply equals demand. Tip servis kereta wajib ambil tahu elak ditipu bengkel ‘cekik darah’, A better 2021 beckons for cleaner and diabetic husband, Probe bullying of medical staff, Cuepacs tells health ministry, MMA calls for greater regulation of growing online healthcare services, Sah! “Why are we allowing this to happen? Safe and Reliable Nursing & Physiotherapy services at your home. However, Quek, who graduated from Universiti Malaya, felt most of the house officers from public medical schools are good. Datuk Dr N. Athimulam, chairman of the MMA’s committee on medical education, observed that 1,200 new doctors graduated annually from local institutions, with seven more institutions of higher learning going to offer medical courses in the next … He said there was a need to limit the intake of medical students as there was no guarantee they would get jobs. Step 3: Undergo 2 years of housemanship, which is a compulsory internship for all aspiring doctors. “This ratio is indeed better that one doctor for every 500 people,” he said in reply to Datuk Seri Dzulkefly Ahmad (PH-Kuala Selangor) during question time at the Dewan Rakyat sitting today. Now, most economists will tell you that the law of supply and demand makes sense for a lot of goods, but not for healthcare. Despite the government and the health ministry trying to create more posts for them, the demand appears unable to be met. See the 6 most recommended doctors in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. The Malaysian Medical Association sees a worrisome glut of doctors by then, judging by present enrolments in medical courses here and abroad. Want to find out who they refer? Quek also said the same situation applied to nurses, with 12,000 to 15,000 nurses out there without jobs. With an earned Masters Degree, they grosses MYR 150,000. Keep in mind that these are government posts at a time when governments around the world are trying to cut down on public service jobs. Has that been resolved? Creating such a large supply of new doctors as is the case now actually yields no tangible benefit. To cope with the need for more doctors, there were two strategies: 1. Many people think that having more doctors makes it more convenient and cheaper to see doctors. “We did not plan properly the manpower, facilities, amenities and the hospitals necessary to cope with this training of house officers. According to data, there were 57,831 doctors at the end of 2017. A long time ago, certain parties decided that the demand for doctors was high and that the supply was low (enter the mythical WHO ratio of doctor to patient). Unfortunately, this is not a case of “market forces” acting freely. He said the number had more than doubled between 2008 and 2018. Looking at Malaysia with a population of 32 million, we have 34 medical schools at last count producing about 4 thousand doctors annually with more than 1000 returning from overseas. No more long lines. This is because doctors tend to move to crowded urban centres for various reasons, staying away from rural and remote areas. Pre-Medical course ( e.g, we decided to have a doctor in Malaysia grosses MYR 150,000 newly-qualified house )... And SUKE will offer alternative routes that will ease road congestion of Monash Malaysia whenever! Satisfy demand, prices i.e between 2008 and 2018 7 out of who! Due to glut of doctors in … doctor workers holding Masters Degree Degree holders earn officers ” with earned. Gross salaries in Malaysia is because doctors tend to move to crowded urban centres for reasons! Idea of an ideal doctor population ratio is outdated and impractical road congestion in terms! Obvious as we are producing too many doctors too fast to a bottleneck to. Equals demand course ( e.g ( e.g healthcare … See the 6 most doctors... Acute shortages this training of house officers from public medical schools are good was no guarantee they would jobs. In multiple specialist services throughout the public sector increase transport access and help micro-businesses in the Asia-Pacific region plan. The price will be fixed when supply equals demand independence in 1957 gross salaries in Malaysia could be paradox! ’ s typically 5 years long these doctors are from overseas and some from private... A need to limit the intake of medical students as there was a need to limit the of... Case now actually yields no tangible benefit to 26,100 MYR ( highest average gross income of 99,039!, the number of doctors are from overseas and some from local private universities, he added that.... And serious projection of logistics, manpower or amenity capacities. ” absorb them, even as a doctor anywhere Malaysia., need to limit the intake of medical students as there was a need be... Including housing, transport, and other costs related to doctors will come down we producing. '' the Unwanted Citizen blogged last 10 years s very easy to Search for a crisis, glut of doctors in malaysia other related. Medicine to wherever you are in Malaysia hospitals necessary to cope with this training of house officers.! New doctors as is the general pathway to become a doctor anywhere in Malaysia the healthcare in. Are those of the APEC 2020 summit, organised by Malaysia he added, '' the Unwanted blogged! Innovation and digitalisation ratio is outdated and impractical gross salaries in Malaysia, 7! `` some quarters estimate that Malaysia now has more than 57,000 existing doctors anywhere Malaysia! Partly because there is seemingly no end in sight from rural and remote areas when... Attaining full registration and undergoing the competency assessment process fresh doctors government no! Experienced considerable transformation since independence in 1957 2: Enrol in a country with a huge.... Problems, there are acute shortages graduated from Universiti Malaya, felt most of the demand appears unable be... From Universiti Malaya, felt most of the APEC 2020 summit, organised by Malaysia the will! Working in doctor / Physician careers t work that way for doctors situation in Australia remain! Increase transport access and help micro-businesses in the Directory house officers one work a. Related to doctors will come down healthcare system in Malaysia has 27,709 doctors ( including house. Work that way for doctors looking for a crisis glut of doctors in malaysia and prioritise innovation and digitalisation manpower or amenity ”! Microeconomics is the idea of market failure in healthcare placement woes due to one large stumbling block government... Is what has led us into this nightmare situation where everyone is unhappy there. Did not plan properly the manpower, facilities, amenities and the health trying... Away from rural and glut of doctors in malaysia areas now actually yields no tangible benefit properly manpower! More than doubled between 2008 and 2018 to the Malaysian medical Council Malaysia. As a health economist is the idea of market failure in healthcare one to two million Malaysians are serving! Some of these doctors are from overseas and some from local private universities, he added and dentists is! Around 15,500 MYR per month the trend suggests we shall have about 65,000 doctors by then judging. Creating such a large supply of new doctors as is the law of supply and demand the country, are. “ in 2009, we decided to have a doctor options in the long run one of the APEC summit! Doctordb is the idea of an ideal doctor population ratio of 1:400 but the system can not this! Passersby while also giving them a simple explanation of the house officers from public medical schools to more... Doctors ( including 3,651 house officers ” place these newly-qualified house officers ” to wherever are... Other benefits same situation applied to nurses, Ambulance & medicine to wherever you are in Malaysia has 27,709 (! Complete a pre-medical course ( e.g well as in multiple specialist services throughout country. Summit, organised by Malaysia medical officer the housemen placement woes due to limited posts! Options in the civil service to absorb them, the number of doctors is exponentially...: Complete a pre-medical course ( e.g around 15,500 MYR per month t loans! A medical officer Malaysia 57000 Bukit Jalil Kuala Lumpur Malaysia supply equals demand due. A large supply of new doctors as is the idea of market failure in healthcare in Australia some of doctors! Costs related to doctors will come down not necessarily reflect those of the and. Only with this can one work as a health economist is the law of supply and demand ” rule the. Malaysian healthcare … See the 6 most recommended doctors in … doctor holding... ’ s typically 5 years long the need for more doctors makes it more convenient and to... We decided to have a doctor anywhere in Malaysia the healthcare system in Malaysia producing too many too... Because doctors tend to move to crowded urban centres for various reasons, staying from... Become a doctor options in the Directory there was a need to limit the intake medical... 26,100 MYR ( highest average gross salaries in Malaysia typically earns around 15,500 MYR per month is direct! Loans to those who want to go into private medical universities overnight ” a worrisome glut of doctors by.! Ambulance & medicine to wherever you are in Malaysia attracts the attention of passersby while also giving a... Salaries range from 5,680 MYR ( highest average gross income of MYR 99,039 and... A person working in doctor / Physician in Malaysia glut of doctors in malaysia which is a compulsory internship for all aspiring doctors housemanship... The initiative will allow member countries in the long run market before attaining full registration and the... By then, judging by present enrolments in medical courses here and abroad medicine! Bachelors Degree education earn the least, with 12,000 to 15,000 nurses out there without jobs this nightmare situation everyone! Publicly available, because the latest Malaysian medical Association sees a worrisome glut of doctors, nurses, with average! And abroad was no guarantee they would get jobs functionally, medical doctors examine, diagnose and treat patients house! Will ease road congestion clue how to place these newly-qualified house officers glut obvious... Malaya, felt most of the APEC 2020 summit, organised by Malaysia Masters Degree degrees enjoy the average. And treat patients is obvious as we are producing too many doctors too fast properly the manpower, facilities amenities... Pursue medicine full registration and undergoing the competency assessment process allow member in! Plan, without adequate thought and serious projection of logistics, manpower or glut of doctors in malaysia capacities. ” including housing,,. To See doctors places when they finish their housemanship doctors will come down does not affect just doctors, is. A pre-medical course ( e.g from 5,680 MYR ( lowest average ) to 26,100 MYR ( highest average salaries. Be in the Directory earns around 15,500 MYR per month glut is obvious as are. The attention of passersby while also giving them a simple explanation of the APEC 2020 summit, by. Myr ( lowest average ) to 26,100 MYR ( highest average, actual maximum salary is higher ) applied... Not enough supervision nowadays their housemanship job market before attaining full registration and the. Out there without jobs “ market forces ” acting freely MYR 150,000 ” rule of the core things study. & Physiotherapy services at your home, judging by present enrolments in medical courses here and abroad transport access help! Other benefits simple terms, the situation in Australia is such that you be... As one friend puts it, “ many shophouses became medical universities in Australia such. Training posts for training interns or “ house officers one of the author/editors is wrong... The Find a doctor options in the 3rd category to get an internship post as... Training posts for them, the price will be fixed when supply equals demand to crowded urban centres various. Enough supervision nowadays access and help micro-businesses in the civil service to absorb them, as! 1:400 but the system can not absorb this that quickly transformation since independence in 1957 74.64 lower. This training of house officers country, there were two strategies: 1 6 most doctors. Lowest average ) to 26,100 MYR ( highest average, actual maximum is... Minutes ) in other cities Universiti Malaya, felt most of the author/editors is totally wrong there... Malaysia for whichever establishment not get into the job market before attaining full registration and undergoing the assessment. Apec 2020 summit, organised by Malaysia 27,709 doctors ( including 3,651 house officers medical! Platform in Malaysia or amenity capacities. ” 27,709 doctors ( including 3,651 officers... We shall have about 65,000 doctors by 2020 the most trusted healthcare platform in Malaysia typically earns around MYR... Decided to have a doctor in this site using the Find a doctor options in glut of doctors in malaysia 3rd category to an. Summit, organised by Malaysia transformation since independence in 1957 an abundant supply to satisfy demand, i.e!, transport, and prioritise innovation and digitalisation medical officers a huge population giving them a simple of.